Tuesday, January 26, 2021

March 2…Classroom Management/School Discipline and the Aims of Schooling

What was school discipline like where you went to school? Looking back, can you remember any teachers who did a particularly good job of managing their class in terms of discipline, etc.? What did they do?

33 comments:

  1. School discipline was not something I had too much personal experience with, and it changed some as I moved schools multiple times. Mainly it was if you did something disrespectful or rude, particuarly multiple times, you would get sent to the principals office. I remember vaguely that my brother had been sent out of the classroom in the hall at our middle school multiple times, so that was another way teachers "disciplined" students in schools I attended. I don't believe the way they did it, personally, was very affective, since I never felt students learned anything from this, especially if they wanted to leave class because they were bored, like my brother in incidents where he was unruly.

    Lastly, this was only in middle school, they used a reward and demerit tickets and points system. You were able to buy small things at the school store during lunch if you gained enough tickets and if you got a demerit or whatever they called it, you lost the end of the year picnic and fair privilege. Again, I don't think this sort of system really teaches students right from wrong in any way, but this is how it is and was.

    Discipline in school should teach students why what they did was possibly wrong or hurtful, and not give empty threats many students don't really care about. Of course it shouldn't be physical, and it should help students realize how they should treat others and want others to treat them. For us to function as a community, we need to respect and care about each other, and you learn this in school; so it goes to say discipline in school should help students want to be better people and understand what they did that caused the need for discipline to begin with.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Personally I don’t remember much about discipline in school growing up because I was an overall “well behaved” student but I do remember some things that I witnessed while in school when it comes to discipline. I remember lunch detention was a huge one. My school had something called “one lunch “ which I don’t think any other school in my county got. This meant that the entire school ate lunch at the same time and you could eat anywhere throughout the entire school. I loved this of course and so did everyone else so this was always the first thing to be taken away if you were to get into trouble. I also remember teachers sending misbehaving students into the hallway which I also did not understand because at this point they were getting exactly what they wanted. They most likely didn’t want to be in that classroom and you have now given them an out but I guess in turn they are now missing information that will turn around and hurt them by missing. I remember in elementary school we had a “school store” where you earned “money” during school hours for behaving or doing certain things and you could spend that money at the school store for pencils, stickers, erasers, etc. I remember the less strict teachers having the least problems with students behavior. Not because they didn’t care but because they realized what was important to care about and what wasn’t. I have often seen teachers going on a “power trip” using their authority to their advantage and disciplining students just because they wanted to when in reality ignoring the situation that wasn’t that serious from the beginning would’ve gone over a lot better. I think it is about picking your battles and having an effective way to handle the battles that you do choose. I think taking away something like “one lunch” in my highschool was a particularly effective method because students loved that time of the day and it was a privilege to be able to attend so if you did not deserve that then I do feel as though it should have been taken away.

    ReplyDelete
  3. (Written by Savannah Barrett) Although I went to several different public schools throughout my life due to moving around, they all had similar ways of disciplining students. Some teachers were a little more strict about things than others, but for the most part it was all the same kind of punishments. If you would not stop interrupting class and the teacher has already asked you to be quite, they would send you to the hall. There was also lunch detention and after school detention. I remember I had a teacher in middle school whose favorite thing to do was give out lunch detentions, and over silly things such as chewing gum. I would say a good chunk of my teachers in the past did a good job at disciplining the class or specific students. A teacher who is good at managing their classroom does a good job at keeping their students calm and controlled. If a student is acting out they do not raise their voice. They pull the student aside and ask them what is wrong or how can they help. They do not just send them away for someone else to deal with. School Discipline should be used to teach rather than punish and, as a result, helps students succeed and thrive in school.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I don’t remember much about school discipline because I didn’t really get in trouble and also because my school was different than the traditional ones. I went to the same school from kindergarten to graduation, with most of the same classmates for that long time. This is why I think we didn’t have a lot of problems in the classroom because we knew each other really well. I went to a Montessori school where problems were resolved in something called “the table of the peace”. If you had a problem with someone, you would go to this table with the person, a teacher, and resolve your problems by talking to each other. This really helped me to understand that as humans we can resolve problems by talking, we don’t need to get physical. This is why I think these kinds of problems were not common in my school. Another thing that I remember we used to maintain the calm in class was something called “the agreement” (I’m translating all these since it was in Colombia and all the names were in Spanish). If a student misbehaves in class, the teacher would fill out an agreement explaining everything that happened and they would sign the paper. Also, this would be sent to the parents and they had to sign the paper as well. Another important thing about my school was that students had a voice, we had opinions, and we were heard. Also, if there was something that we would not agree with, it was fine for students to let the teachers and the rest of the people that worked there know about it. We were all a community and everyone's opinions were valid and heard.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I honestly do not remember much about discipline within the classroom because I personally was not a student who needed to be disciplined very often. What I do remember the few times I got in trouble in elementary school I remember vividly because I never wanted to get in trouble and when I did it devastated me. It was even worse when there were rewards systems in place in the classroom or behavior charts that everyone was rewarded or deducted points from based on their behavior that day. I had a teacher who used the clip chart of red, yellow, and green circles like a stop light and everyone had a close pin with their name on it attached to the stop light. It was embarrassing when your clip got moved as it was always done in front of the class when a student was being difficult or did not do what they were told. These charts are now prohibited in many school systems as they should be. Another thing I experienced a lot through all grade levels was the students getting kicked out of the classroom if they were doing something that the teacher did not like or was against the rules. That to me always felt cruel and demeaning because in that moment you kick a student out you deprive them of so much. The answer to discipline in the classroom is not the immediately take away their education. There are better ways to handle disciplining a student than directly calling them out and traumatizing them in the classroom and in front of their peers. Often when students act out or have difficult day, there are underlying issues they may be facing. It is so important to connect with your students and make sure that they are doing okay mentally and emotionally. It is also so important that teachers themselves are open and honest with their students when they are having a tough time. I had a teacher growing up that would take out her anger on us as students when she was having a hard day. We never truly knew what we were doing wrong and would get punished as a class by having recess taken away, being yelled at, or silent work. We never really knew what we did wrong and discipline for it pretty often. If a student does something wrong it is important to have a conversation with them to help them understand why what they did was wrong or better understand where the behavior may stem from. Communication is key in the classroom when it comes to discipline.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Me personally, I was a good student behaviorally speaking. I never got suspended, had in school suspension or even detention. I can recall a few times in elementary school that the whole class or even whole grade would get in trouble. I had one teacher, who wasn’t even a teacher, she was a teacher’s aide, that used to give us laps around the track as discipline. Looking back on it years later I think it was absolutely ridiculous and something like that would be considered inappropriate in today’s society. There were sometimes that we would have to do 50 laps. We couldn’t go play at recess until the laps were done and if it took more than one day then she would just deduct time until we had no more left to complete. My peers and I, for the most part, were unruly so it did not take much discipline.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Being the daughter of a teacher gave me an idea of the patience and work it takes to be an educator therefore, I always felt for my teachers and tried to do my job as a student so that they could do their jobs as teachers. Most of my teachers did really well with creating boundaries in the classroom. One teacher in particular had a very hard time with it. She was a young, first year high school chorus teacher and being in a room of 30+ girls was hard for her to manage. Eventually she felt it was too much and quit halfway through the year. In comparing her to other teachers, she lacked control over her classroom. Having a respectable amount of control of your class is not only important to the teacher, but for the students who need to learn as well.

    ReplyDelete
  8. For me, I grew up fearing school discipline so I don't have much experience with receiving discipline at school. But I could name about two experiences I had and both had to do with the moving your number or card to a new color or space. The first time I was in kindergarten and I got in trouble for talking during nap time, then for making too much noise from jumping trying to move my name to a lower spot. The second time I was in 3rd grade and I forgot to make my lunch choice because I was doing assigned work the teacher told us to do, so that event followed with me sobbing in the class library because I thought I was doing the right thing by following the teachers instructions. Both times I felt this was a poor choice in discipline because both instances had to do with my ADHD that I no control over and after those two instances I was then determined to never get in "trouble" again. Looking back the only good discipline techniques I saw were in middle and high school. Those techniques were basically communication by allowing the student to explain why they are displaying certain behaviors and then the teacher talking with them on how they (together) can change the certain behaviors that display as disrespectful or uncivil. But if a physical fight or any rule breaking that went against the "code of conduct" that was usually turned to the discipline of the administration.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I moved from Florida to Virginia in the third grade. In Florida, the environment was extremely different than in Virginia. The teachers were less involved in helping and disciplining the children due to the large number of students in each class. Once I moved to Virginia, the dynamics changed inside the classroom. I felt more cared for and helped when I needed even if that was being disciplined. I was also a very energized child. I was constantly going or talking and this sometimes led to consequences. As a child, I never understood why I was disciplined for that till I became a camp counselor myself. I learned a lot about kids and the way they act and respond to rules. Every child reacts differently to the way someone reprimands them. I learned it's best to calm them down and allow them to tell you what happened in a mature way. This allows them to know I am there for them to help with the situation. I had many teachers that would just yell and punish both parties to "fix" the situation faster but it usually never ended well.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I went to 2 different elementary schools in different counties and they actually had very similar disciplinary actions. We had silent lunch, a table in the middle of the cafeteria next to the teacher's table, if we were rude/ disrespectful/ or didn't follow the rules, this actually carried into middle school as well. If I ever got in trouble, the worst I got was silent lunch or sent into the hall way. Once I got after school detention because I threw a lollipop to my best friend at the time, didn't really feel deserving of that one. I honestly cannot remember any times I specifically had a teacher with good class management, they all disciplined in the same way and when I was in early elementary school I had the "Green, yellow, and red lights" or a version of that to tell how we were for the day. I mean if I ever got the yellow card I would sob in the back of class because there was no chance in getting back to green. So unfortunately I cannot think of good experiences with class management just the negative experiences.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I did not have a lot of experience with discipline because I purposefully flew under the radar, so I only know the second hand. I do remember feeling that suspension or expulsion was ridiculous. As the podcast mentions, this can be mistaken as a reward. This was used quite a bit where I went to school. If a student had multiple behaviors, they were sent home for a few weeks, might require an appointment with a psychiatrist before returning in serious cases, but then they would just come back. I had friends that were suspended and I remember them struggling to get caught back up. I have probably talked about this teacher many times in my education classes, but I had a teacher my 2nd and 4th grade year that everyone loved. She was moved into my 4th grade classroom after our teacher quit in the middle of the year; it was a rough class. She came in and we all remembered her as being sweet so that's what we expected, but she came in and made us earn that back. She was never rude, but she was stern. Let me tell you, that class BEHAVED after that. Eventually, we got the sweet, fun teacher back. Through it all though, we always knew she was doing it because she cared and she was being stern because she expected more of us. I don't know if I think this is the best approach, but it worked well. She got us in line and we had a great classroom community for the rest of the year.

    ReplyDelete
  12. While I personally seldom faced traditional discipline at school, I attended an overcrowded, underfunded public high school, which means I had ample opportunities to witness how they handled discipline. It is interesting to reflect upon these experiences, because I see now that they punished students differently based off of their grades (honors/AP classes versus standard). In the non-honors/AP classes, discipline involved a call home or being sent to the principal's office, perhaps in-school or afterschool detention. In the upper level classes, however, it was psychological - since most students were focused on getting into the college of their dreams, threat of a disciplinary mark on their permanent record was enough to keep everyone in line. I remember several times in my Latin classes the teacher going on about how misbehaving now (read: showing up to class as the bell rang, talking, passing notes) equated to throwing away our futures and dooming ourselves to "a life of mediocrity and failure". This sentiment was echoed in many of my upper level classes - it was drilled into our minds that any faux pas, any bad behavior, any misjudgement, no matter how big or how small, would result in our dreams being tarnished and our lives amounting to nothing. Upon reflection, I can clearly see that this constant threat was perhaps more harmful than traditional disciplinary techniques may have been, at least to my own psyche. We were not threatened by the concept of after school detention or a call home, but rather, a failed future. Not everyone took these threats seriously, but I know many did, and developed a fear of "breaking the rules" (even trivial ones) for fear of massive, life-altering repercussions later in life. I do not think that this was ethical, but it was effective in keeping a classroom of 14 to 18 year olds relatively tame. I wonder now, though, at what cost? Was the silence of a high school homeroom really worth the lasting sense of impending doom left in many? A regime followed out of fear is not a mark of good leadership.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Growing up homeschooled I never really encountered discipline in the classroom. My classroom was in my own home with my family or in large groups of other homeschooled students who knew their parents were in the building and that everyone knows everyone’s families. There was no misbehaving, there was never the opportunity (not that any of us were really looking to do that we were all thought at a very young age how to behave in this class setting). I didn’t attend a public school until mind way through high school, and often times discipline is not really needed when you get to that age, especially in the classes I was taking. We had ISR and ASR but I never knew anyone who had to take part in that. Most of my classes were calm and if a problem showed up the teacher would normally just tell us to stop what ever we were doing and we would listen. The only time I ever encountered and issue in the classroom was my senior year of high school, I was taking 3 online classes in one class period to try and makeup for classes I had missed coming into the school that I needed for graduation. Most of the other students in the class were there because they either didn’t want to be in an in person setting or they had already taken a failed the class at school and didn’t want to take it with the same teacher again. We had a few instances where students would misbehave or simply spend the hour and half not doing their work and our teacher who was just overseeing our work would have to intervein. Often this just meant that the teacher would sit next to the student to monitor what they were doing more closely or tell the whole classes we weren’t allowed to talk for the rest of class while we did our work. I wouldn’t say that either of these methods was overly amazing or even helpful 100% of the time but it is the only in class discipline I have ever encountered.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Discipline at my school wasn't very intimidating, but it was very biased and the administration picked favorites when it came to suspensions and expulsions. Most troubled students use school as a safe place from home, and suspending them for ignorant reasons and sometimes putting them in a toxic environment is completely inhuman to me. I feel as though guidance and a path in the right direction is a better solution in some scenarios. However, sometimes discipline is the only way to get through to someone. My high school math teacher was very smart as using incentives and guided students to do the right thing before they do the wrong things. She would only send them out if they weren't fixing their issues. With her giving them a chance to fix themselves, they are more open to talk about it and realize things. I also use this method in my Pre-K class, because it works so well on older and younger children.

    ReplyDelete
  15. In terms of discipline from my schools, I don't really remember anything significant. It was the standard, if you misbehave you got sent to the principles office. I remember one time in 1st grade, I guess I was being disruptive, so my teacher sent me down to my old kinder garden class. It was as a timeout, I remember the feeling of embarrassment I guess being with the younger kids. I guess it was to teach me a lesson.

    I never got detention before, not to say I never got in trouble or anything. But I never went to detention, the worse I got was I was sent home for the because, I had a "little fight" with my friend in 1st grade. Little fight meaning we pushed eachother.

    Example for one of my teacher's in highschool, we went to this play the drama class was having during on our periods. And my class decided, to make a lot of inappropriate noises when the lights went off. I didn't make any noises but I did laugh a little. (I was 14 ok?). Anyway, my teacher brought us back to the classroom, and made us do this assignment. She told us she was very embarrassed.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I feel as though I have mainly witnessed negative experiences of disciplining. Mainly teachers having breakdowns for having lost control of the class or having angry/hurtful outbursts. I did have a few teachers who I felt were good at disciplining- one I always think of is an English teacher from my freshman year in high school. She was one of those teachers that if you causing a bit of a distraction in class, she'd give you a look like "I expect better of you" (not to be confused with "I am disappointed in you", and you knew that out of respect for her you should probably quiet down. I feel as though the teachers who treated the students with the same dignity and respect you would have for anyone outside of school were very good about having control in class. From my experience, the teachers who experienced outbursts or breakdowns were the ones who felt that they should have the final say in the classroom, that the kids should basically shut up if they willed them to. They wanted to control a classroom, not necessarily manage it and the various personalities that were in there. I think some teachers like to rule out of fear- fear of failing, fear of getting sent to detention, or fear of disappointing someone and I don't think it's really fair to treat a child like that. Every student is willing to learn but sometimes they don't know how to learn yet. They don't know that maybe note-taking doesn't work for them, and maybe they prefer talking about it. Or, referencing Maslow's hierarchy of needs, sometimes a student simply needs a break from their reality at home, and look to school as a break from that reality. When an educator shows that they care and respect a student, I feel as though they may have an easier time gaining the respect of their classroom, resulting in a class that is more easily manageable.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Anna Bagley

    Throughout elementary, middle, and high school, I have seen many different ways of disciplining. In the younger grades I remember a system using cards. Every person started with a green card everyday and if someone broke a rule, the teacher would ask the student to change their card to yellow, which is seen as a warning, and if they misbehaved again they would have to change their card to red which means they would get in trouble. Overall this system worked good because if you ended the day with green you get a sticker for your chart and once your chart was full you got a prize, so students did not want to change their card. In middle school, I saw it change to just getting sent to the office and that would usually end up in in school suspension where they do work in a room alone or detention. In high school, kids would always get sent to the office and individual decisions would be made there, usually suspension or explanation of the rules broken and a warning. In classes where people would be disrespectful, I saw some teachers handle it well, call students out even when they would continue to talk back, and others that would just kick people out of class. I think talking about the action works better because the problem is being addressed and hopefully students can talk it out with the teacher rather than get sent away and have the built up tension in their relationship.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Most of the time in school I was a well behaved kid, but in elementary I wasn't all that. I remember I was standing in line and this boy was making fun of me and then hit me. The teacher came through before it got bad and broke us up. They gave both of us detention for I believe a week. However, they didn't solve the problem that was still there after are week was up. I kept having problems with other teachers in school, the bus, and kids around my neighborhood. They only gave out punishments to me and the other kids, but it kept on happening. I can't really remember teachers managing their class good. However, the teachers that made the class fun and talked to the student to a more personal level. Had a easier time managing their classes and making students get better through the school.

    ReplyDelete
  19. deepmala gupta- I was a pretty calm kid in school, like I did what I had to do and i always listened. But i think it was mostly because I knew if i got in trouble my parents would be extremely upset. I guess my parents provided a better form of discipline than any of the schools i went to. Like for elementary school, if you got in trouble, depending on the teacher, you could get a "think sheet" which was basically like getting written up and then your parents would have to sign the paper. I did have this teacher in 6th grade that would handle problems on his own rather than taking it to our parents which was cool. Basically he would, sit with the person causing issues or whatever the situation was and talk it out with them.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I don't remember much about being personally disciplined in school. I just remember that my elementary school had very different methods of discipline. Some teachers were extreme to a dangerous extent and other were simple to a dangerous extent. For example, one of the fifth grade teachers hated when kids leaned back on their chairs and would always yell at them for it. One day a kid was doing it again so she yanked back on his seat and he fell, which resulted in a concussion. She was fired. I think all teachers at each school should have some sort of agreement towards the style of punishment in order to not confuse the kids.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I worked in the office for some of my time during school and I just remember all of the kids getting into trouble and sometimes them getting kicked out because of terrible thing and sometimes they would just be sent to iss or maybe just have a talking to the higher ups. I just felt like if you were good with the higher ups then you did not have to worry about getting into much trouble if you we were close with them. Just overall I felt like there could have been much more that they could have done with everyone.

    ReplyDelete
  22. In my experience, every teacher disciplined students differently. I was very quiet and well-behaved in school so I rarely got into any trouble. I remember my third grade teacher would add on minutes for us to sit after class in silence if the class was misbehaving during the school day. I think this was really unfair because elementary students have no control over their transportation, like if they rode the bus they would've gotten on late or could've risked missing the bus. I feel like their should be more communication between the teacher and students when it comes to disciplining students.

    ReplyDelete
  23. when I was a child discipline at my school was not as harsh as some others. I remember when I was in third grade and we had the typical color chart to change when we did not no behave, this was kind of embarrassing and I suppose it did encourage us to behave more. My 4th grade teacher would have fun Fridays and if you had a great week and did not get talked to at all you would get pizza and candy and we were able to listen to music. I usually always got to participate in fun Fridays because I was typically a good kid but I saw how the kids who did not get participate would act and they usually seemed very upset. I think classroom management is having the children respect the teacher and making sure the teacher also respects the children and student as well. Embarrassing a student for something they did wrong, when kids are younger and they are still learning right from wrong they need to be talked to more. They need to be sat down and listened too. Now there are sometimes where you may need to speak with a student in private and maybe remove them from the environment if they are disrupting the other students and that's okay. When things are done more privately it gives students a moment to stop and think instead do of looking to their peers for the way they may react because they see their fellow student being punished.

    ReplyDelete
  24. I remember some of the harsh ways that teachers and administration used to discipline us in elementary and middle school. If someone did not participate in class, their recess would be taken away from them, and 9 times out of 10, that student was having a terrible day and simply did not want to talk. There would also be silent lunches to some students who were not quiet in class, which in my opinion is completely dehumanizing and can be super humiliating. I think it is easy to maintain a good classroom environment if everyone is on the same page and there is a mutual respect for the students and teachers. When a child gets embarrassed by an instructor, that can sit with them for a very long time and can lessen that respect they once had for that teacher, so I think that there is a certain way to handle moments of conflict in the classroom without causing a huge scene.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Throughout my public school education I got in a few times. I would get in trouble for talking or not paying attention. In most cases they would first give me a warning, but in front of everyone which was slightly embarrassing. After I continued acting out they would move me away from everyone else in the class. For my third incident they would make me leave the classroom. I then would get sent to the principal, parents called and have lunch detention. This continued for most of elementary school until middle school when a teacher sat me down and actually talked to me instead of discipling me right away. I was soon diagnosed with ADHD so my behavior changed not long after but the way that teacher handled has always stuck with me. All that teacher did was take the time to sit with me and ask me what's going on instead of jumping to conclusions and thinking I'm a bad student because I couldn't pay attention. I feel like more teachers should take a more one on one approach.While the educating is obviously a huge part, forming good relationships and bonding with students is what teaching is all about. We should want to see our students thrive.

    ReplyDelete
  26. I really do give props to my high school French teacher because she always thought before reacting, which is super hard to do. She let us talk in class, but we had to talk in French, so if we weren’t actually studying our vocab we’d have nothing to do, but study our vocab. If we were caught talking in English she’d then come up to us and talk in way more advanced French about what we were talking about in English and if we couldn’t respond in French, we’d get a participation point taking off for the week. So, she gave us a chance of redemption. I also broke down in class and started crying so hard once, she let me cry without pointing out that I was all puffy from crying, and then motioned that I could go into the hall and told the class to just play a game. She asked if I was being bullied at my table and really just made sure I was okay. I was crying over a boy. (Yay me and my bleeding heart). But I really admire her for always thinking about resolving a problem with communication before going to any kind of punishment.

    ReplyDelete
  27. The discipline in elementary school was pretty standard. I went to 3 different elementary schools, one of them being a private catholic school. They all believed in listening, no talking when the teacher is instructing, be kind to your peers, etc. They did, however, have different methods of enforcing behavior. One school I went to when I first moved to Richmond, they had a stop light in the lunchroom and green meant good, but when behavior in the lunchroom was getting loud or crazy, the light went to yellow as a warning, and if the light got to red it was silent lunch for the entire lunch room. It was effective because we then kept ourselves responsible for our behavior. The private school was catholic so when we would in trouble we went to the nuns and that alone was taunting. Of course one school used behavior charts and would redeem things like treats or homework passes if we kept a good streak.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Looking back at how my schools enforced our discipline, they tended to do so with routines. In elementary school we would have a certain order to stand in when going to places. I found that made it easier for teachers to make sure we were not being disruptive. However, school discipline can become too overbearing. An example would be my freshman year of high school. The school day started at 7:30am. One day I was 5 minutes late, because of car problems, and due to that I had to sit in in- school- suspension for the first half of the day. I was confused as to why I was in suspension doing nothing, when I could be in class, only for being 5 minutes late. That to me was too much of discipline and they were not being understanding, empathic, and they were over using their control. Educators need to reevaluate the age of who they are working on, and question how to their rules and regulations are affecting students.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Reshmi BhattacharyaMarch 4, 2021 at 1:54 PM

    Hey there, everyone!

    It's kind of funny because I remember having the most magical time in my first grade classroom where my teacher lead with love and structure. This cozy experience contrasted starkly with my second hard experience where my teacher was strict and demand obedience. This affected me negatively and actually made me a more negative person. However, my first grade teacher made me more positive and open. From what I remember the things she did well were: 1) having a comfortable learning environment 2) keeping on a routine 3) prioritizing humanness. Through this classroom management I thrived as a student and hope to do the same for my students in the future.

    ReplyDelete
  30. During my days in public school, I was generally well-behaved. I would cry even if one of my teachers raised their voice at me for simply talking too much during class. I got sent to the principal’s office once in fourth grade for accidentally tripping my friend and making them cry, and I thought it was the end of the world! My general experience with discipline was, similar to Amanda and many others, based on a reward/punishment system. I believe that it was widely used and accepted since the concept was the easiest for young people to digest and adjust their behavior in accordance with. Like Madison, Annie and Ashlyn, I vividly remember the red, yellow, and green cards. I would cry if I was even moved to the yellow, and I can’t even imagine how the kids in the red felt. Being in the yellow or red meant being left out of some classroom activities, such as recess or getting to play with blocks or Play-Dough. In high school, we functioned on a similar stoplight system with the usage of our phones and iPods during lunch time. If we behaved, we were able to use our phones at lunch, sit wherever we wanted, and talk to our peers. If we misbehaved or someone left a mess from the last lunchtime, we would be put in a yellow or red zone, where we would not be able to use our phones or even talk at the table. I feel like that system works to an extent, as people are driven to socialize with each other and the rewards are motivating, but it sometimes ignores the deep-set problems that other students may experience who would overlook the small rewards when misbehaving due to their pre-existing problems at home and in their environment.

    ReplyDelete
  31. School disciple looked like sitting in a principal's office getting lectured about why what you did was wrong and how you need to tighten up and correct your behavior. It also looked like sitting outside of the classroom when you did something the teacher deemed inappropriate. Looking back, I can see that traditional disciple was/is very isolating. Depending on why the student had the behaviors they did, this could be good or bad. I honestly cannot think of a teacher in my k-12 schooling that did this well. Classroom management in a small town is almost comical because (like other places) its not about asking the why questions but its about changing the behavior(s) as quickly as possible. If I had been approached with a behavioral shift and practical tools to manage my emotions as a child rather then just being told no. I probably wouldn't have to be doing all of this deep diving in my 20's to understand how/why I function the way I do and also how to change it.

    ReplyDelete

April 6...Ask a Teacher Advocacy Expert

In light of last week's readings on teacher evaluation and this weeks readings on teacher activism, come up with two questions to ask an...